Why You Keep Attracting Wrong Partners and How to Do Things Differently

If you find yourself repeatedly drawn to partners who aren’t right for you, the problem might not be random. Your subconscious often guides your choices based on familiar patterns from your past, even if those patterns are unhealthy. This can lead to cycles of emotional unavailability, toxic dynamics, or mismatched values.

Here’s what you need to know:

• Your subconscious craves familiarity: Traits from your early relationships, like those with parents or caregivers, shape what feels "normal" in love – even if it’s harmful.
• Attachment styles matter: Emotional distance or conditional love in childhood can influence your adult relationships, making unhealthy dynamics feel like home.
• Intense chemistry can mislead: That spark you feel might be unresolved emotional wounds, not genuine compatibility.
• Healthy relationships may feel unfamiliar: Stability and respect can seem "boring" if you’re used to chaos or intensity.

Want to know more?

Why You Keep Attracting the Wrong Partner (And How to Fix it)! With Dr. Karishma Ahuja

How Your Subconscious Shapes Partner Choices

You might think you’re consciously choosing a kind, reliable, and emotionally available partner, but your subconscious often has its own agenda. Instead, on its own it steers you toward what feels emotionally familiar – even when that familiarity isn’t healthy.

This explains why you may keep gravitating toward partners who share traits with people from your past, even if those traits once caused you pain. Your subconscious brain identifies these patterns as "home", even if "home" wasn’t safe or nurturing.

What makes this even trickier is how natural these subconscious preferences feel. That magnetic instant chemistry or inexplicable pull toward someone? It’s often your psyche’s way of replaying old dynamics in an attempt to heal unresolved wounds. These deep-seated tendencies trace back to your earliest relationships, forming a blueprint for how you approach love.

#1 – Childhood Experiences Shape Your Dating Patterns

Your first relationships – typically with parents or caregivers – lay the groundwork for what psychologists call your attachment style. This internal framework shapes your understanding of how relationships work, influencing everything from how much closeness feels comfortable to what you interpret as love.

For example, if you grew up with an emotionally distant parent, you might find yourself drawn to partners who are similarly unavailable. Your subconscious equates love with emotional distance, so overly available partners might feel uncomfortable or even "wrong."

On the flip side, children who had to earn love – perhaps through achievements or by taking care of others – often grow into adults who are attracted to partners needing "fixing." Your subconscious has learned to tie your value in relationships to what you can do for others, rather than simply being yourself.

Even positive childhood experiences can create challenges. If you were overly protected or constantly praised, you might struggle in relationships where you’re not placed on a pedestal. Alternatively, you might find yourself giving more than you receive because that dynamic feels normal to you.

These patterns are so deeply ingrained that they can feel like part of your personality. You might believe you are just "naturally" drawn to mysterious people or that you "prefer" partners who keep you on your toes. But often, these preferences are your subconscious recreating the emotional environment of your childhood.

#2 – You Are Drawn to What Feels Familiar

Your brain is wired to seek out the familiar, confusing it with safety. This instinct, rooted in evolution, builds on the patterns you learned early in life.

When you meet someone new, your subconscious quickly scans for emotional cues that remind you of the past. Does their communication style echo your father’s? Do they handle conflict like your mother? These familiar traits can create a powerful sense of recognition – what feels like destiny is often just your brain identifying patterns.

This is why you might feel an intense connection to someone who ultimately isn’t right for you. Your subconscious isn’t evaluating compatibility with your current needs and goals. It’s responding to familiar emotional dynamics.

The pull toward familiarity is especially strong with negative patterns. If you grew up surrounded by drama, chaos, or emotional highs and lows, calm and stable relationships might feel boring – or even wrong. Your nervous system has learned to associate love with intensity, so peaceful relationships can seem like they’re missing something.

It is exactly this reason why healthy relationships might feel unfamiliar at first. Partners who are emotionally available, consistent, and respectful might not spark the instant chemistry you’re used to. Learning to recognize this difference is a vital step toward breaking unhealthy cycles.

#3 – Intense Chemistry Isn’t the Same as Love

That overwhelming "spark" you feel? It’s often fueled by a cocktail of stress hormones and neurotransmitters like cortisol, epinephrine, dopamine, and low serotonin levels^[1]. While it might feel exhilarating, this rush can cloud your judgment and impair critical thinking. Instead of being a sign of true compatibility, this kind of chemistry can lock you into repeating old, unhealthy patterns in your relationships.

Think of it like a sparkler: dazzling and intense, but ultimately short-lived and unable to sustain a meaningful connection^[1]. Though it may feel magnetic, this fleeting chemistry often serves as a distraction from the deeper, unresolved issues influencing your choices in partners.

How DO You Change Your Dating Patterns?

Breaking out of unhealthy relationship cycles starts with honest self-reflection and intentional changes. By looking at how past experiences shape your decisions and examining your dating history with a fresh perspective, you can uncover the recurring patterns that influence your choices.

#1 – Ask Yourself Questions About Your Dating History

• What type of person are you consistently drawn to?
• How do your relationships usually end?
• What emotions arise at the start of relationships?
• What role did your family dynamics play?
• What’s your timing with relationships?

Recognizing these patterns is the first step toward protecting your emotional well-being and setting boundaries that align with your needs.

#2 – Set Boundaries Right Away In A New Relationship

Boundaries are essential for safeguarding your emotional health and defining what you will and won’t tolerate. Many people who struggle with unhealthy relationships have difficulty setting boundaries, often out of fear of rejection or a tendency to put others’ needs first.

• Start small. Begin by setting clear, manageable boundaries in everyday situations.
• Communicate directly. Don’t expect your partner to guess your needs.
• Enforce consequences. If someone repeatedly crosses a boundary, follow through.
• Pay attention to their reactions. Healthy partners will respect your boundaries, ask questions, or apologize when needed.
• Protect your time and energy. You don’t need to be available 24/7 to respond to messages, solve problems, or sacrifice your personal goals to accommodate someone else.

#3 – Rewire Your Approach to Dating

Breaking old patterns starts with understanding and managing your emotions.

Take stock of how your subconscious might be influencing your attraction to someone. Are you thinking this person “isn’t your type?” Or perhaps there is no chemistry. If these things have shaped your past partner choices, its time to do things differently.

Pay attention to your emotional state during dating. Notice when you’re drawn to someone who exhibits red flags you’ve seen before. Instead of acting on instinct, pause and ask yourself: What’s fueling this attraction? Is it the thrill of drama, the pull of familiar dysfunction, or genuine compatibility?

Before each date, set clear intentions. Shift your mindset from seeking someone to "complete" you to exploring compatibility. Ask yourself questions like: "Does this person’s communication style align with mine?" rather than "Can I change how they communicate?"

#4 – Get Help from a Relationship Coach (like me!)

If reflecting on your own isn’t enough, working with a relationship coach can provide the guidance and accountability you need. A skilled coach helps you uncover blind spots, challenge limiting beliefs, and craft strategies tailored to your unique patterns to help individuals break free from toxic relationship cycles.

Your Next Steps Towards Your Happily Ever After

To break this pattern of attracting the wrong kind of partner, focus on self-awareness around how your past experiences influence your choices. Reflect on your dating history and set clear boundaries, Remember, understanding your past is the first step toward creating the relationships you deserve.

Seeking professional guidance can also provide tailored strategies to help you break old patterns and build healthier ones. The time and energy you invest in understanding yourself will ripple through every part of your life – not just your romantic relationships.

Remember: your past doesn’t define your future. With the right tools and dedication, you can break free from harmful cycles and create the relationships you truly deserve.

Related Blog Posts

• Should I Stay or Leave? 5 Key Questions

Mitzi Bockmann